Woozle Wuzzle
BDBXML and document modifications

There are a number of problems with updating XML documents in an XML store. The primary problem is that XQuery 1.0 does not have a facility for updating documents. The XQuery Update Facility Requirements exists but it clearly states "the WG does not intend to produce a Recommendation from this Working Draft" which leaves me with a big fat question mark over my head. This has caused each XML DB vendor to provide their own update mechanism. And this leads to the topic of this post:

BDBXML is a decent XML DB but it's somewhat rough around the edges. When updating documents it is common to get the following error:

Cannot perform a modification on an XmlValue that isn't either Node or Document type, errcode = INVALID_VALUE

To make a long story short, you cannot specify a doc('...') in the XmlQueryExpression that you specify to any of the XmlModify modification methods. The documentation implies this but does not drive the point home. Given that all non-modification uses of XmlQueryExpression require some sort of "navigation function" (collection('...'), doc('...'), etc) it feels odd not to specify it for modfications.

Comments
Post a comment













Remember personal info?






Creative Commons License Unless otherwise expressly stated, all original material of whatever nature created by Rob Grzywinski and included in this weblog and any related pages, including the weblog's archives, is licensed under a Creative Commons License.